Share
Few industries understand the value of building talent better than manufacturing. Learning a trade from someone who has spent thirty years perfecting it is practically the sector’s signature. Walk around most plants and you’ll still see it working, with former apprentices now training the next ones.
Even that tradition is under strain. Make UK reports that apprenticeship starts fell by 42% in the seven years to 2025. Ask where tomorrow’s data, automation and AI capability will come from, and the answer gets vaguer still. For many manufacturers, digital skills are something brought in from outside, when a project demands it and the budget allows. Others haven’t got that far. The debate is usually framed as “build versus buy”. The more uncomfortable question is whether many firms are doing either.
Two clocks are counting down
The first clock is demographic. More than half of manufacturers expect to lose between 6% and 20% of their workforce to retirement over the next decade, and in some trades nearly half the workforce is already over 50. When those people leave, they take knowledge that rarely exists on paper: why a line was set up the way it was, which workarounds keep it running, what a machine sounds like just before it fails.
The second clock is technological. Data, automation and AI are evolving faster than most businesses can absorb them. The people best placed to spot the opportunities are rarely the ones who’ve spent decades in the business. That’s not for lack of ability; it’s hard to know what you don’t know.
Every year of inaction widens both gaps at once. Meanwhile, the firms that started building mixed capability years ago aren’t standing still.
Why the old model struggles with new skills
The traditional apprenticeship works because knowledge flows in one direction. A newcomer is surrounded by people who know the machine, the process and the product intimately. It’s an excellent way to teach someone to run a line you’ve run for decades.
It works far less well for data or AI integration, where there may be no expert in the building to learn from. A recent data analytics graduate may understand the tools better than colleagues with twenty years’ service. That’s a measure of how fast the technology moves, rather than a criticism. But it means the familiar model, where experienced staff teach and newcomers learn, can’t produce these skills on its own.
Why buying isn’t the answer either
If digital skills are hard to grow, the obvious alternative is to buy them. For many smaller manufacturers, buying means a vendor or integrator who installs a system, trains a few people and moves on. The right partner relationship makes that work. The wrong one leaves you with patchy support, or locked into a technology ecosystem that was never chosen objectively.
The person manufacturers really need is harder to buy: someone who understands both the factory floor and the data that describes it. Experienced people with that mix are rare and expensive, because the firms that have them have usually built them.
There’s a deeper problem too. In our conversations with manufacturers across Sussex, almost all are acutely aware that digital transformation matters. What they struggle with is prioritising it alongside the daily demands of keeping production running. That rarely calls for another tool. Someone needs full ownership of the job.
The apprenticeship that runs both ways
The apprenticeship model doesn’t need replacing, it needs reshaping into a different kind of relationship. Experienced staff pass on how the plant really works and why it was built that way. The junior hire is given explicit permission to question those decisions and propose improvements.
Research from the Digital Futures at Work Research Centre (Digit) shows what that combination can look like. Researchers including the University of Sussex’s Dr Zahira Jaser studied one of the world’s most digitally advanced factories, a plant in northern Italy recognised by the World Economic Forum. Its managers had deliberately chosen not to replace experienced workers who adapted more slowly to new systems. Instead, they paired that long experience with digitally fluent younger colleagues and gave everyone time to adjust. The plant’s transformation cut lead times by 82% and raised labour productivity by 31%, and the researchers found that this patience strengthened efficiency rather than holding it back.
“There is hype around AI that sometimes obfuscates the importance of human experience, human manual and relational skills, and a community of practice,” explains Jaser, an Associate Professor in Organisational Behaviour. “Our research shows that AI in manufacturing adds value when people work together in a coordinated, collaborative way, and when experienced workers can guide its implementation.”
What are you building?
Smart manufacturers build and buy. The ones that will struggle are doing neither: waiting for the perfect experienced hire while the knowledge in their building retires and the technology moves on.
Nobody has to build alone. Apprenticeship providers, skills bootcamps, government funding and programmes such as Made Smarter are putting real momentum behind this problem. The question for every operations and engineering director is simple: what are you building?
Tech Talent Champions is a free recruitment service from Sussex Innovation, helping Sussex employers find and hire emerging talent for AI, data and digital roles. On 18th November, graduates from our data science and analytics bootcamps will take on a live challenge set by the 1066 Manufacturers Group in Hastings. Find out more and request a place here. Or browse our candidates, with no sign-up needed, at TechTalentChampions.com.